California Gets it Right: Gay Marriage Legal!
California Overturns Ban on Gay Marriage
In striking down the ban, the court said, "In contrast to earlier times, our state now recognizes that an individual's capacity to establish a loving and long-term committed relationship with another person and responsibly to care for and raise children does not depend upon the individual's sexual orientation, and, more generally, that an individual's sexual orientation -- like a person's race or gender -- does not constitute a legitimate basis upon which to deny or withhold legal rights."So they get it. And California, such a place, is now able to offer to its gay citizens the rights it affords to the rest of them.
Johannah texted me the news. I've been cheery ever since. The only cloud on the horizon: a ballot measure for voters in the fall that would overturn the Supreme Court. Let's hope the landslide for the Dems this fall will overwhelm any GOP attempt to reinstate the ban.
Here's Salon.com's article.
Republicans have, in the recent past, used court decisions like this one -- and subsequent initiatives and referendums at the ballot box -- to motivate their party's base to come out and vote. They'll most likely try the same thing in California. A coalition opposed to gay marriage had, even before the decision, already submitted more than 1.1 million signatures in favor of putting an initiative on California's ballot this November that, if passed, would amend the state's constitution and override this decision. But the actual value Republicans could gain from doing this in a state like California, which is dependably blue when it comes to voting for a president, seems small. And there'll be little chance to use the California decision effectively elsewhere: There are only so many times you can have voters decide these sorts of questions, and most of the key swing states have had similar measures on their ballots during one important national election or another this decade.


3 comments:
I guess it is good news. I just don't expect it to last past November.
I certainly don't expect to be able to take advantage of it. Even if I did have someone special in my life I don't think I'd want to be married.
What I'm most afraid of is that Californians will pass a constitutional amendment like the one in Michigan that is being used now to deny any benefits to gay couples that are offered to married couples such as health insurance.
As the economy gets worse, people love to find a group to demonize, and I know who the first group will be.
I suppose in the long run this decision will make a difference, but the outlook for the near future isn't too bright.
baycityjohn,
Understand your reticence about the legislation in Michigan but I still think it is good news nonetheless even if it is ultimately overturned by CA residents. Maybe this ruling will untimately be two steps forward and one step back...but it is still one very important step. I think if you look at the history of gay rights in the some of the EU countries I think we will follow a similar pattern in the U.S. ...albeit somewhat delayed but eventual.
R. Michael
Keep the faith Bay City John! There are more of us who support gay marriage than there used to be. They can't keep banning it forever. Our young people are growing up and voting and they don't care about the dire predictions of their parents that gay marriage leads to The End of Civilization as We Know It!
I think the outlook is pretty bright. We fight on!
Post a Comment